April 2002
SAN DIEGO—According to a University
of California–San Diego study released Monday, sexism is rampant throughout
the natural world, particularly among the highest classes of vertebrates.
“When we first decided to examine attitudes
and behaviors toward gender roles among non-humans, we were wholly unprepared
for what we would find,” said Jennifer Tannen, leader of the UCSD research
team, a joint venture between the school’s zoology and women’s studies
departments. “Females living in the wild routinely fall victim to everything
from stereotyping to exclusion from pack activities to sexual harassment.”
Nowhere is the natural world’s gender
inequity more transparent, Tannen said, than in the unfair burden females
assume for the rearing of offspring.
“Take the behavior of the ring-neck
pheasant,” Tannen said. “After mating, the male immediately abandons the
hen, leaving her responsible for the total care for the chicks. For the
single mother-to-be, there is no assistance, either in the form of a partner
or child support. Nor is there any legal recourse. It’s despicable.”
Tannen said pheasants are typical of
the natural world, where a mere 5 percent of animal species mate for life.
Among species that do form lasting pairs, the situation barely improves:
Females must remain close to the nest to incubate eggs, nurse, and keep
watch over the burrow while males are free to go off hunting and fishing
with their friends.
“The sexist attitude that child-rearing
is ‘women’s work’ is prevalent throughout nature and has been for generations,
probably since reptiles first developed mammalian characteristics in the
Triassic period,” Tannen said. “Sadly, most creatures never pause to challenge
these woefully outdated gender roles.”
Tannen stressed the need to hold high
those rare examples of species that do form caring, mutually supportive
relationships.
“Wolves, beavers, gibbons, and a small
African antelope known as a dik-dik all live in stable, monogamous pairs,”
Tannen said. “Other animals need to look to them as positive models if
we are to have any hope of one day creating an ecosystem of understanding
and respect.”
More seriously, in addition to an unfair
division of labor, nature is rife with sexual abuse and harassment. The
UCSD study estimates that in 2001 alone, more than 170 trillion cases of
abuse occurred in the world’s forests, grasslands, and oceans – all of
them unreported.
“During the act of mating, the female
moose is subject to excessive biting, nipping, and herding,” Tannen said.
“The male has no qualms about using sheer, brute force to overpower his
sex partner, and the female, accustomed to this sort of rough treatment
after millions of years of it, doesn’t even realize there’s something wrong.”
“Then, when it’s time for the bull
moose to complete the sexual act,” Tannen continued, “it’s over in about
five seconds, with no regard to female pleasure whatsoever. Typical.”
Adding insult to injury, Tannen said,
the bull moose then heads off to mate with dozens more females over a period
of two to three weeks, justifying his behavior as “part of the Mardi Gras-like
atmosphere of ‘mating season.'”
With other species, darker situations
unfold. “To mate, the male Galapagos tortoise simply immobilizes the female
with his weight, which, as far as I’m concerned, qualifies as non-consensual
sex,” Tannen says. “Female southern elephant seals gather in large groups
during mating season, and each group has a small handful of males who control
them like a harem. It’s sick.”
When female animals refuse to play
along with prescribed gender roles, Tannen said, they are demonized. For
example, female foxes, known throughout the animal kingdom for their aggressiveness,
are labeled “vixen.”
“We’ve all heard the lurid tales about
the female black-widow spider, who kills and eats her mate,” Tannen said.
“The truth is, male spiders encourage their partners to kill them because
it increases the time spent mating and, thus, the number of eggs fertilized
by his sperm. But no one condemns the male for his part in this destructive
relationship.”
UCSD researchers identified 24 distinct
male behaviors designed to perpetuate gender inequity and preserve the
prevailing power structure. Among these dominance-asserting behaviors are
chest-puffing, plumage-spreading, and antler growth.
The UCSD study is not without its detractors.
Glen Otis Brown, author of Forced To Strut: Reverse Sexism In The Animal
World, countered that male animals are victims of “the beauty myth”
as much as females.
“When given a choice, female green
tree frogs gravitate toward males that call the loudest and most often,”
Brown said. “Female Poecilia reticulata [guppies] go straight to
the most brightly colored males. But when males evolve exaggerated secondary
sexual traits to attract the opposite sex, suddenly they’re the
bad guys.”
Tannen conceded that both genders have
suffered as a result of sexism.
“Other than sexual size dimorphism
due to same-sex competition, males benefit little from the gender inequity
that so strongly favors them,” Tannen said. “In a world where interactions
are rooted in competition, not cooperation, both females and males
are being denied the right to form meaningful relationships.”
Annie Secunda, a Boston-based females’-rights
advocate, said swift action must be taken to address the problem of sexism
within the animal kingdom.
“We need to provide tigresses, hens,
and all other females in nature with outreach programs and support networks,”
Secunda said. “We also need to impose standards through intervention. The
males of all species need to hear loud and clear the message that this
kind of animal behavior is not acceptable.”
Secunda conducts numerous workshops
aimed at creating female-friendly biomes and promoting the health and positive
self-image of females on both land and in the sea. She also strongly advocates
the legalization of infanticide, which would enable females to devour their
newborn offspring when resources are limited.
Secunda spent much of 2001 in the Amazon
rainforest, working to create safe spaces for female animals. These efforts,
however, yielded mixed results: Females have avoided the lighted walkways
she built in several dangerously dense areas, and leaflets encouraging
females to learn how their own bodies work were ultimately used to line
dens for the rainy season.
Far from discouraged, Secunda said
she plans to embark on an intensive study of the sexuality of flora.
“Multicellular plants alternate sexually
reproducing and asexually reproducing generations, with each plant producing
both male and female gametes,” Secunda said. “It seems many plants have
moved past conventional notions of male-female gender altogether. It’s
so liberating, I can’t help but have hope for all those so-called ‘higher’
species of animals.”
Reprinted from The Onion, March 13, 2002.
Help us maintain freedom in teaching, research and scholarship by joining SAFS or making a donation.
